I heard a radio ad yesterday from a law firm trolling for people who want to blow the whistle on their companies for fraudulent use of PPP funds. The ads say whistleblowing’s the right thing to do and whistleblowers can cash in by getting a piece of what the feds take back.
Sometimes whistleblowing can be the right thing to do and some whistleblowers do receive financial gain. But you can also pay dearly. For anyone hearing these ads, keep reading.
I say that because I’ve never been a whistleblower if you look at the dictionary’s definition of one, but I’ve been treated like I had. And it can be brutal.
Whistleblowers, by definition, go outside their organizations to alert authorities, regulators or law enforcement to an issue going on within their organizations. And one study showed that 84% of federal whistleblowers had attempted to alert people internally to an issue–a textbook example of staying within the chain of command.
I was simply an employee discretely trying to get my organization to deal with a ticking time bomb of an employee in my company who had made threats and complaints against people throughout company leadership and had scared them and their decision-making process into submission. They called her ‘The Arsonist” for her destructive abilities and openly feared what she might do to them if triggered by any action against her.
And I quickly learned what an organization with a bad culture and weak leadership can do. That is, people with reasonable concerns are eliminated.
And, in my book, The Arsonist in the Office: Fireproofing Your Life Against Toxic Coworkers, Bosses, Employees, and Cultures, I describe it as the moment when I didn’t know if I needed an HR meeting or law enforcement. “The Arsonist” had begun to behave in ways not seen since the last time you turned on the Lifetime Network’s Movie of the Week.
When I spoke up internally and asked my leadership to put an end to the aberrant behavior I was getting, I put them in a position where they felt the need to act. The cover-up had gotten out of control and was about to be exposed.
And act they did. It came down to a decision that someone had to go–and who would they throw overboard–the employee they had already feared might destroy them with leaks, lawsuits and allegations from the outside or me–the one who felt embarrassed to even broach the subject of the chaos, much less go outside HQ.
So I was terminated. And then threatened by HR with being buried in legal fees if I spoke to anyone externally about what had happened.
Termination and threats are often included in the whistleblower experience, but I wasn’t even a whistleblower.
Whistleblowers, who often remain inside the company at least at the beginning, face additional problems if they are identified, including:
- Retaliation–it can come through loss of wages, loss of friends, loss of promotions. Your colleagues will reflexively distance themselves, as who intentionally stands next to the target of a corporate air strike. Or you’ll have your reputation dragged through the mud with charges designed to muddy the waters.
- Career options–whistleblowers are often forced out of their companies or move on after feeling threatened or isolated within them. Finding that next job may be difficult. If you think the threats and retaliation ends once the employment ends, you’d be wrong. And imagine the storyline you’re forced to either embellish or avoid when asked why you left your last employer. You’re disarmed.
- Whistleblowers usually don’t get rich–it’s a fact of life that they don’t. Not for most people. And in cases I won’t share publicly, the path can lead to financial destruction.
- The mental toll–whistleblowers wake up every day wondering if all the stress, uncertainty and grief is worth it. And worth it for their families. Again, I’m not a whistleblower, but I can tell you the path has its difficult moments.
And what does it do to the companies that conceal, concoct and villainize their employees raising a concern? Nothin’ good.
- higher employee attrition
- safety risks
- lower employee feedback about other serious problems
So what’s on the positive side? I never have to worry about whether I had the integrity to speak up against something deeply wrong and dangerous inside my organization. And I’m helping people throughout the world–executives, managers, or ordinary employees–deal with broken organizations or the problems that can end careers and destroy cultures. And no threat or termination can stop that.
If you hear these ads or you’re in any other tough decision that requires speaking up, know the benefits. And the costs.
Pete Havel is a speaker, trainer, consultant and author of The Arsonist in the Office: Fireproofing Your Life Against Toxic Coworkers, Bosses, Employees and Cultures . The book is available through this site and is available on Amazon in kindle and audiobook form as well. He fixes broken cultures and helps organizations deal with their toughest challenge: people problems. You can reach him at firstname.lastname@example.org or 855-NO-ARSON for interviews, events, and any other questions.